Albuquerque And Mesa Personal Injury Lawyer

Compensatory Damages vs. Punitive Damages

Tell Us What’s Happening. Get The Legal Help You Need.

Table of Contents

When victims of personal injury in Arizona or New Mexico pursue legal action, the goal is often to seek compensation for the harm they’ve endured. However, it’s important to understand that not all damages in a personal injury case are created equal. There are distinct categories of damages available to plaintiffs: compensatory damages and punitive damages. This article will explain the differences between the two, and under what circumstances they may be awarded.

Compensatory Damages: Making You Whole Again

Compensatory damages are the most common form of financial recovery in personal injury cases. Their primary purpose is to compensate the injured party for the losses they’ve suffered due to the actions of the at-fault party. There are two main types of compensatory damages:

  1. Special Compensatory Damages: These are intended to cover specific, quantifiable financial losses incurred by the plaintiff. Examples include medical expenses, lost wages, property damage, and out-of-pocket costs related to the injury.
  2. General Compensatory Damages: These damages aim to address more intangible losses, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of consortium, and the detrimental impact on one’s quality of life. General damages are less concrete but equally significant.

Punitive Damages: A Deterrent and Punishment

On the other hand, punitive damages serve a different purpose. While compensatory damages aim to make the injured party “whole” again by reimbursing them for their losses, punitive damages focus on punishing the wrongdoer and deterring them from repeating similar actions.

These damages are awarded less frequently and are only granted in cases where the defendant’s conduct was especially egregious or demonstrated a willful disregard for the safety and rights of others.

Arizona’s Punitive Damages Statute

In Arizona, pursuing and obtaining punitive damages in most personal injury cases can be challenging due to specific legal limitations. Courts in Arizona have established strict criteria for awarding punitive damages, reserving them for only exceptional circumstances. 

To qualify for punitive damages in Arizona, it’s generally necessary to demonstrate that the negligent party was acting with what the courts describe as an “evil hand” and “evil mind.” What does this mean?

Arizona courts have determined that an individual behaves with an evil hand and an evil mind when they:

  • Had the intention to harm the victim.
  • Engaged in conduct that they knew was unsafe and likely to cause harm to the victim.
  • Committed acts of such extreme recklessness that it’s reasonable to assume they intended to harm the victim or consciously disregarded the substantial risk of harm resulting from their behavior.

It’s important to understand that punitive damages are generally not available in cases of simple negligence or carelessness. Arizona law reserves them for situations where the defendant’s actions display a much higher degree of wrongdoing, such as deliberate harm or blatant disregard for the safety and well-being of others.

Examples of Punitive Damages

Punitive damages are typically associated with cases involving extreme negligence, malice, or deliberate wrongdoing. Some common scenarios where punitive damages might be considered include:

  • A company knowingly selling a defective product that causes harm.
  • An individual driving under the influence and causing a severe accident.
  • A corporation hiding evidence of a product’s danger, putting consumers at risk.

Differences Between Compensatory and Punitive Damages

Several critical distinctions set compensatory and punitive damages apart:

  1. Purpose/Intention: Compensatory damages aim to restore the injured party to their pre-injury condition, while punitive damages intend to punish the wrongdoer and deter future misconduct.
  2. Award Frequency: Compensatory damages are far more common and are typically awarded in most personal injury cases. Punitive damages are the exception and only come into play when the defendant’s actions warrant punishment.
  3. Calculation: Compensatory damages are calculated based on the actual financial losses incurred by the plaintiff. For general damages, the legal process often takes into account previous awards and established case law to decide on a reasonable value.
    • Punitive damages, on the other hand, lack a set formula and are often determined at the discretion of the jury. Generally, in Arizona, the following aspects are taken into account when assessing the suitability of punitive damages:
      • The gravity of the defendant’s actions.
      • The duration of this conduct.
      • The extent of the defendant’s awareness regarding the actions or any efforts made to hide them.
      • The financial worth of the defendant.
  4. Limitations: Some jurisdictions impose limits on the amount of punitive damages that can be awarded, while compensatory damages typically have no such restrictions. 

The United States Supreme Court has ruled that when punitive damages are more than nine times the compensatory damages, it’s typically considered unconstitutional. For instance, if you receive $100,000 in compensatory damages, an award of $900,000 is generally regarded as unconstitutional and will likely be adjusted to a more reasonable figure.

In Arizona, the standards are even more stringent, with the state’s Supreme Court suggesting that a ratio of 4:1 is typically seen as unconstitutional. However, it’s important to note that there is no fixed or mandatory ratio between compensatory and punitive damages.

In a personal injury case, understanding the distinction between compensatory and punitive damages is crucial. While compensatory damages are aimed at making the injured party whole again, punitive damages are reserved for cases of extreme negligence or malicious intent. 

If you’re unsure which type of damages might apply to your situation, consult with an experienced personal injury attorney who can provide guidance tailored to your specific circumstances.

When facing the complexities of personal injury law, having the right legal representation is paramount. At Wood Injury Law, we are committed to helping you navigate the intricacies of your case. If you’ve been the victim of a personal injury in Arizona or New Mexico, contact us today for a free consultation to explore your legal options and seek the compensation you deserve. Your path to justice begins here.

Scroll to Top